This issue marks the beginning of a five-part storyline that delves into the aftermath of the events depicted in Identity Crisis. The narrative focuses on the Justice League grappling with internal conflicts and the repercussions of their past decisions, particularly concerning the mind-wiping of Dr. Light and Batman. The story was penned by Geoff Johns and Allan Heinberg, with artwork by Chris Batista.

The actions taken by some Leaguers, as revealed in "Identity Crisis," stand revealed. Worse, they've been undone.